September 17, 2025


GOP Defections Thwart Censure Motion Against Rep. Ilhan Omar

In a narrow vote that underscored internal GOP divisions, several Republicans broke ranks to join Democrats in defeating a measure aimed at censuring Rep. Ilhan Omar. The proposed censure, spearheaded by Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.), sought to condemn Omar for her alleged remarks about the late conservative figure Charlie Kirk and to remove her from all committee assignments.

The vote tally stood at 214-213, signaling a significant blow to the censure effort. Omar has denied making the contentious comments, a defense bolstered by unwavering support from House Democrats. House Minority Whip Katherine Clark dismissed the censure attempt as "political theater" aimed at boosting Mace's gubernatorial aspirations, accusing her of trying to monetize the controversy.

Among the Republicans who voted against the measure were Reps. Mike Flood (Nebraska), Jeff Hurd (Colorado), Tom McClintock (California), and Cory Mills (Florida). Their opposition was pivotal in the outcome. Mills defended his decision as a stand for First Amendment rights, while Flood suggested a more measured approach, recommending an investigation by the House Ethics Committee prior to any punitive action.

In remarks following the vote, Mace expressed dismay at her party colleagues' decision, describing it as "unbelievable" and "gross." She was overheard mentioning that she had reported the dissenting Republicans to former President Donald Trump, highlighting the internal tensions the vote provoked.

The aftermath of the vote also saw Rep. Omar appreciative of the Republican dissenters, praising their commitment to constitutional principles. She took a swipe at Mace, wishing her "the help she needs."

The incident has sparked further partisan skirmishes, with Democrats like Rep. Greg Casar (D-Texas) calling for a retaliatory censure against Rep. Cory Mills, who is currently under an ethics investigation. Additionally, Rep. Marc Veasey (D-Texas) hinted at possible impeachment proceedings against high-profile GOP figures in the Justice Department.

This episode is the latest in a series of confrontations involving Omar, a figure frequently targeted by GOP criticism. Previously, she was removed from the House Foreign Affairs Committee by a Republican vote. The current situation, however, reflects growing concerns among some Republicans about the repercussions of such partisan conflicts, especially with the possibility of future Democratic majorities.

As the dust settles, Democrats appear poised to retract their retaliatory measures, a decision influenced by previous outcomes like the failed censure attempt against Rep. LaMonica McIver (D-N.J.) earlier this month. This episode underscores the complex interplay of partisanship, strategy, and constitutional rights that continues to shape the dynamics within the U.S. House of Representatives.

*Reported by Ben Jacobs and Calen Razor.*