November 2, 2025


A Fractured Dream: Pervasive Pessimism and Distrust Shadow American Sentiment

America is grappling with a profound crisis of confidence, reflecting a nation deeply divided and increasingly skeptical of its future. According to a recent POLITICO Poll conducted by Public First, a staggering two-thirds of Americans believe that the government frequently lies to its citizens. This sentiment spans the political spectrum, uniting 64 percent of Donald Trump supporters and 70 percent of Kamala Harris backers in their distrust.

The poll, which comes nearly a year after Trump’s reelection, paints a grim picture of national sentiment, with 49 percent of Americans convinced that the country's best days are behind it. This number surpasses the 41 percent who remain hopeful about the future, highlighting an overarching mood of pessimism.

Democrats, in particular, are feeling the sting of disillusionment more acutely than their Republican counterparts. A significant portion of Harris voters—twice as many as those who voted for Trump—feel that America's prime is a thing of the past. Jennifer McCoy, a political scientist specializing in partisanship at Georgia State University, suggests that these attitudes often reflect whether one's preferred party controls the White House.

The survey also reveals deep concerns about the American Dream. Traditionally seen as the promise that one's hard work can lead to upward mobility and a better life, this cornerstone of American ethos is now questioned by nearly half of the population. Forty-six percent of respondents declared the American Dream dead, a sentiment especially prevalent among younger Americans.

Economic challenges such as stagnant social mobility, unaffordable housing, and persistent student debt are cited as key barriers to achieving this dream today. McCoy points out, "In economic terms, social mobility has been getting worse and worse...and young people especially are feeling that."

Political polarization is another significant concern, with 59 percent of Americans believing that divisiveness has worsened over the past five years. The poll indicates that most Americans surround themselves with friends who share similar political views, further entrenching this divide.

Despite these challenges, a surprising 52 percent of Americans believe that radical change is necessary to improve life in the U.S. This sentiment is particularly strong among younger generations and Harris voters, with one-third of the populace even advocating for a revolution.

Yet, amidst the prevailing gloom, a sense of national pride persists. Nearly two-thirds of Americans still express pride in their nationality, suggesting a resilient, albeit strained, patriotic spirit.

As the country continues to navigate these troubled waters, the call for unity and a renewed commitment to the common good has never been more urgent. Maury Giles, CEO of Braver Angels, emphasizes the need for hope and confidence, stating, "The vast majority of this country understands that what is happening right now is not healthy, it is not sustainable."

In this era of uncertainty, the quest for a renewed American Dream and a less polarized society remains a pivotal challenge, one that will define the nation's path forward.