As President Donald Trump navigates the turbulent waters of his second term, the unity of his electoral base, famously donned in red MAGA caps, is beginning to show signs of fracturing. This emerging split among his supporters poses a significant challenge for the Republican Party as it looks toward the 2028 elections, recent findings from The POLITICO Poll reveal.

While more than half of Trump’s 2024 voters identify as MAGA loyalists, a substantial 38 percent do not see themselves within this group, according to the poll conducted among 2,098 U.S. adults from November 14-17. This distinction between MAGA and non-MAGA Trump voters is critical as it highlights differing perceptions and expectations, particularly concerning economic issues and party trust.

Economic responsibility appears to be a significant point of contention. While 47 percent of MAGA supporters still attribute the current economic conditions to the Biden administration, only 26 percent of non-MAGA voters agree. Moreover, when it comes to handling the economy, 88 percent of MAGA adherents trust the Republicans, compared to a lesser 63 percent among their non-MAGA counterparts.

Healthcare, another critical area, further illustrates this divide. Amid struggles to extend Affordable Care Act subsidies, 85 percent of MAGA voters trust the GOP over Democrats to reduce healthcare costs. In contrast, only 55 percent of non-MAGA voters feel the same, with some even leaning towards Democratic trust.

Personal financial outlooks also vary notably between these groups. A majority of MAGA Republicans (73 percent) are optimistic about their financial future over the next five years, unlike 57 percent of non-MAGA Republicans. This optimism extends to their current financial situations, where 52 percent of MAGA Republicans see improvement over the past five years, compared to a nearly split perception among non-MAGA Republicans.

These internal discrepancies extend to voter behavior in the recent off-year elections, where shifts in Latino and young male voters back to Democrats were noted. While a robust 92 percent of MAGA Republicans supported Republican candidates, only 62 percent of non-MAGA voters did the same.

This split within the Trump electorate underlines a broader issue for the GOP: converting Trump’s 2024 coalition into a stable, unified Republican base for future elections. With less than four years until the next major electoral tests, the party faces the daunting task of bridging these divides to maintain its competitiveness.

As the GOP strategizes for the future, understanding and addressing the varied concerns and loyalties within its voter base will be crucial. The party's ability to adapt to these internal dynamics could very well determine its fate in the 2028 elections and beyond.

Interested in more political insights? Consider signing up for POLITICO's Playbook newsletter.