January 12, 2026


U.S. Commission on Civil Rights Reverts to Democratic Control Amid Controversy

In a surprising turn of events, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights has shifted back into Democratic hands due to Republican inaction, potentially impacting ongoing investigations including a high-profile probe into antisemitism on college campuses. This shift occurred after Senate Majority Leader John Thune did not fill a vacant seat following the expiration of GOP appointee Gail Heriot's term in December, resulting in a 4-3 Democratic majority.

The change in control comes at a crucial time as the commission is deeply involved in scrutinizing the Trump administration's aggressive measures against universities and the dismantling of federal civil rights offices. A spokesperson for Thune stated that they are addressing several appointments and anticipate filling the commission's empty seat soon.

Amidst this backdrop, Chair Rochelle Garza, appointed by Democrats, remains at her post despite alleged attempts by the White House to demote her. Garza has faced threats of detention and removal by federal authorities, a tactic she denounces as intimidation. "If we are here to champion civil rights, we have to do it above board and cannot let anybody push us around, not even the president," Garza asserted.

The commission's work, particularly its investigation into campus antisemitism, continues unabated, with universities and several federal agencies like the Department of Education and the Department of Justice cooperating. The final report on this investigation is expected in September.

The political tension within the commission was highlighted last year when Heriot revealed that there had been threats aimed at coercing Democratic members to conform to White House directives. These threats reportedly included job losses for staff of Democrat appointees and physical removal of Democratic chairs. Despite these pressures, the commission has not acted on the White House's directive to replace its leadership, maintaining its independence.

Heriot, speaking at a contentious meeting, expressed her inability to support the administration's nominees under such coercive conditions. "I have no reason to believe that these threats are coming from President Trump himself or from his top advisors, but it does seem to be coming from somewhere in the administration," she disclosed.

As the commission awaits further information from federal agencies, Garza remains steadfast in her position, vowing to resist any unlawful attempts to oust her. "I’m not going to let anyone threaten or intimidate me into doing something I know is wrong," she declared, emphasizing her commitment to uphold the principles of civil rights amidst ongoing political strife.