November 15, 2026

Republicans face a widening rift within President Donald Trump’s 2024 coalition after losing control of the House and Senate, according to a new post-election poll.
The POLITICO Poll, conducted by PF Global days after the midterms, found that self-identified MAGA voters and other Trump supporters drew sharply different conclusions about the defeat. MAGA voters were more inclined to absolve Trump and urged the party to move closer to him. Non-MAGA Trump voters were more likely to blame the president and wanted Republicans to move away from his agenda.
About one in five non-MAGA Trump voters said they backed Democratic candidates in the midterms. A majority attributed the loss of Congress to Trump’s actions in office, while 59 percent described him as a loser of the election. Nearly half said Republican candidates should have broken with him on the economy.
MAGA voters were divided over responsibility for the losses but remained confident that Trump could recover. Overall, just over half of Trump voters believed he could make a comeback, and they were more optimistic about the Republican Party than about the president.
“As the [GOP] spends the next two years figuring out who it is and what it stands for, these divisions will only be further exposed,” Republican strategist Doug Heye said.
Trump has argued that Republicans would have won had he been on the ballot. In a post-election “60 Minutes” interview, he acknowledged that the Iran war and resulting high gas prices may have contributed to the defeat, while also citing voters’ dissatisfaction with some candidates.
Republicans must now navigate disagreements over policies including mass deportations, tariffs and the Iran war. The split also hangs over the 2028 presidential race, as some congressional Republicans warm to a potential Marco Rubio bid and question whether Vice President JD Vance is too closely tied to Trump’s agenda.
MAGA Trump voters, however, strongly preferred a nominee who had served in the administration, underscoring the challenge of charting a new course without alienating the party’s most loyal voters.