November 17, 2026


Murkowski Faces Serious Challenge in Bid to Lead GOP Appropriators

Sen. Lisa Murkowski’s expected path to the top Republican position on the Senate Appropriations Committee is facing a serious obstacle, with two GOP senators predicting that the panel’s Republicans will instead choose Sen. Jerry Moran of Kansas.

The Alaska Republican is the committee’s most senior eligible GOP member and had been widely expected to succeed outgoing Chair Susan Collins of Maine, who lost her reelection bid earlier this month. But Moran’s challenge threatens to upend the Senate Republican Conference’s longstanding reliance on seniority in selecting committee leaders.

“Moran will win,” one of the senators said Tuesday. Both senators were granted anonymity to discuss the contest candidly.

Republican appropriators will vote in January, after new GOP senators join the panel. Their choice will be a recommendation, however, and must be approved by the full Senate Republican Conference. It remains unclear how the conference would respond if the committee recommended passing over Murkowski.

A third Republican senator, who said the outcome was uncertain, advised Moran to consult party leaders because losing a committee leadership position could have broader implications for the conference. Some Republicans fear that bypassing Murkowski could encourage more challenges to senior members and deepen party divisions after a bruising election cycle. Conference rules do not require committee leaders to be the most senior members.

Senate Majority Leader John Thune said last week that he had not intervened but had urged Murkowski and Moran to “talk it out.” Sen. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, a GOP leader and senior appropriator, said Tuesday that the two senators would meet this week.

Both have also been privately making their case to colleagues. Neither senator’s spokesperson provided comment Tuesday, and Moran did not explain his reasons for challenging Murkowski when asked last week.

Murkowski, who has broken with Republicans on prominent votes, will be the Senate’s most moderate remaining GOP member in January. Democrats see her as a potential negotiating partner on spending, though they are staying out of the contest.

Republicans will lose five Appropriations Committee members in January, including several likely Murkowski allies. Their replacements have not yet been determined.